For owners and presidents who’ve decided new grads aren’t worth the trouble — I judged a college sales competition this week, and it gave me a look at a rich vein of talent.
No, and if you’ve made “veterans only” your hiring rule, you’re screening for the wrong characteristics. The best predictor of how good a salesperson is going to be isn’t the number of years on the résumé. It’s whether the person is still learning, and I just spent a morning watching a room full of college kids out-question people twice their age, which educated me about where real sales talent comes from in 2026.
If you own or run a B2B company and you’ve been telling your recruiter to bring you seasoned reps and nobody green, this one’s for you, because I think your rule is hurting you.
This week at the ISSA Show I spent the morning as a judge for the Global Collegiate Sales Competition, which was in its second year at the show (schedules didn’t allow me to judge last year). I judged one section, eight college students running live sales role-plays of initial discovery calls in front of judges, and I’ll be honest, I walked in with very modest expectations and walked out genuinely encouraged. A few of the eight were still raw, which is exactly what you’d expect from people this early. But two of them were good enough that I would have handed them to any client of mine and bet on them making money in their first year. Two out of eight, ready right now, and the rest had real potential. There was nobody in the section to whom I would have said, “you know, there are a lot of other great professions out there.”
Why were college kids out-questioning veteran reps that I’ve seen?
The scoring in these role-plays leaned heavily on questioning (and you know how I feel that 80% of the chance to win or lose the sale is based on the questions you ask), and that’s where these kids floored me. They asked questions I have spent years trying to pull out of veteran salespeople, and too often, I lose that fight. They asked incisive, well-aimed questions that opened the buyer up instead of steering him toward a pitch. I’ve run training rooms full of people with twenty years in the field who won’t ask those questions, and here were nineteen- and twenty-year-olds doing it on a stage, under pressure, in front of judges.
And make no mistake – these kids were nervous. In some, it showed during their role-play in slightly quavering voices and a bit of a tremble as they took notes. I saw others walking the halls after the round was over, and I could see that they were breathing deep. But they got past it – and hell, I was nervous the first time I made a sales call! Weren’t you?
It isn’t that the kids are smarter than your veterans. It’s that they were just taught how to do it, they’re still hungry, and they haven’t yet picked up the habits that make experienced reps stop asking great questions or learning new ones. A green salesperson who’s been coached well and still wants to get better will out-perform a comfortable veteran on the fundamentals, and I watched it happen eight times in one morning.
Many times in my career, I’ve seen new salespeople come in and immediately start taking off. The veterans grumble, “Ah, it’s beginner’s luck.” Nope. It’s beginner’s enthusiasm, and that enthusiasm is contagious to customers and it’s what keeps people growing and learning.
The real divide isn’t age, it’s learning
Owners miss this when they sort candidates by years of experience. Experience only compounds if the person is still learning. A rep who stopped growing ten years ago doesn’t have ten years of experience, he has one year of experience repeated ten times, and you’re paying a premium for the repetition. This is particularly true of job-jumpers, of course, but it can still be true of veterans with the clean job history of long tenures.
A lot of veteran salespeople quit learning somewhere along the way. They got comfortable, they decided they already had a system, and they stopped getting coached and started coasting on relationships and tenure. That’s not a knock on all of them, and the best veterans never stop sharpening the saw, but it’s common enough that “experienced” and “good” don’t necessarily go together in this profession. The college kids I watched had the one thing you can’t train into somebody who thinks he’s already arrived, which is the appetite to keep getting better.
What makes this even more important is that we are in a time where salespeople need to learn and change. If my Navigator Buyer Study is proving nothing else, it’s proving that the way people buy things, and what they expect from salespeople, has changed seismically and fundamentally – and most salespeople have not kept up. Your buyers are probably ahead of you, and they’re standing and looking back and you and saying, “Hey, get up here if you want my business.” These kids are primed and ready for this type of buyer. That doesn’t mean that your veterans can’t be; it means that your veterans have to get out of their comfort zones. Or these kids are going to take their collective lunches.
So what should an owner actually do about it?
Go find out whether there’s a sales program at a college near you, because there are a lot more of them than there were a few years ago, and most owners have no idea they exist. These programs are turning out kids who’ve been trained in real selling, competed at it, and been coached hard, and they are blue-chip candidates that almost nobody in your market is recruiting.
Build a relationship with the program. Offer to judge a competition, speak to a class, or take a few students to coffee. You’ll get a look at the talent before anyone else does, and you’ll be hiring trained, coachable, hungry people at the start of their careers instead of fighting over the same tired pool of “experienced” reps everybody else is chasing. And when you do interview a new grad, stop screening for years and start screening for trajectory. Ask what they’ve learned in the last year and how they learned it. The answer tells you more than a decade of job history.
And I can now tell you this from experience: the coaches and kids appreciate people who volunteer to help. After judging on Wednesday morning, I kept getting stopped and thanked from people who were involved in the competition, even if they weren’t directly involved with my section. Real world help matters to these people.
What do I have to do to make a young salesperson successful?
Now that I’ve told you how awesome these kids are, I have to tell you that they can still fail. The most likely cause of failure in young salespeople is when they aren’t properly onboarded and trained. I’m going to be crystal clear here: you have to have the patience to build a quality 90-day onboarding program. The old “here’s your desk, here’s your phone, good luck, you’re on your own” system doesn’t work anymore. It never really worked well anyway, but it’s gone from being “highly recommended” to being “mandatory.” One fact about Gen Z is that, for the most part, they have led pretty structured lives thus far with scheduled activities. Gen X was told to go play and be back by dinner. Gen Z had play dates. You have to be patient enough to build the structure, show them how to work, how to sell your stuff, and what you’re all about – but the rewards are worth it.
Did this change how I feel about the profession?
It did, and I didn’t expect that going in. I hear a steady stream of pessimism about young people and selling, that they won’t pick up the phone and nobody wants to do this work anymore, and I spent a morning with eight kids who were not only good at it but excited enough about sales to make a competition out of it. I left feeling better about the future of this profession than I have in a while.
There’s a lesson in it for your current team, too. If a college sophomore who’s been selling for eight months can out-question your twenty-year veteran, the problem isn’t the veteran’s age or ability – I know of salespeople in their 70s who are still learning, growing, and kicking ass. The problem is that somewhere along the line he stopped being pushed to learn, and that’s fixable, but only if you quit treating experience as the finish line and start treating it as something that is a foundation to build upon.
The kids are coming, and they’re better than you’ve been told. The real question is whether you’ll go find them before your competition does.
This article asks a hard question about college kids. The harder one is about your own team: are they still learning, or coasting on tenure? A Sales Navigator Diagnostic tells you where they actually stand against the way buyers buy now. Learn more and request one here and find out before your competition’s new hires do.
Frequently asked questions
Should I stop hiring experienced salespeople?
No. Experience is valuable when it’s still compounding. The point is to stop using years in the field as your filter and start screening for whether the person is still learning, because a coachable new grad will often beat a coasting veteran on the fundamentals that actually close business. Ask questions during the interview process like “what’s the last sales book you read?” Or, “what resources do you use to continually develop your skills?” Honestly, you’ll probably be disappointed with a lot of answers.
Where do I find these college sales programs?
Many universities now run formal sales programs and compete in collegiate sales competitions. Search for a sales program or a sales center at the colleges near you and reach out to the faculty who run it. Most are glad to connect strong students with employers. Use AI to research this if you like – just like I told you to research prospects with AI last week.
How do I evaluate a new grad with no track record?
Screen for trajectory instead of history. Ask what they’ve worked to get better at in the last year, how they handle being coached, and put them through a live role-play if you can. How they ask questions under pressure tells you most of what you need to know. And use a third-party assessment. I like the Profiles Sales Assessment, and I use JobMatch Assessment as my partner.
Aren’t young salespeople weak on the phone and in person?
That’s the assumption, and it didn’t survive what I watched. The kids in that room were poised, prepared, and sharp in live conversation. Training and enthusiasm beat the stereotype. I didn’t see them on the phone, of course – but remember now that prospecting requires channel fluency. If they can learn live sales calls like that, they can learn the phone and the other channels.

